Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

He is.


You believe that people in countries that fund college tuition genuinely don't understand that it comes from general taxation?


Not only that, but the OP mentioned tuition specifically. Tuition is the fee you may have to pay to attend college. If there is no such fee to pay, whether the money comes from donations, taxes, a trust fund, a lottery, intellectual property royalties or what have you, there is indeed no tuition.


Do we have some kind of trophey to give this gentlemen? Like 'stubborn and presumptious of the year'?

Its like writing to tell people they are illiterate


Which Gentleman (or lady?)? supernova87a, himinlomax, or vt85


My original reply to

> loquation

> Living in a country, where there basically is no college tuition in the US sense and scale, this sounds all so alien to me. There's nothing "utopian" about it. From my perspective, it's more of an ideological problem than anything else.

was responding to my perception that his or her written / implied sentiment was conveying that it's so strange that students would need to work to be able to afford to go to college. That we should have a system where students have a special right to get something for free as an entitlement of society.

Now, whether that is a good policy is a legitimate question. My response was to point out that the above kind of thinking regards students as a special class of people who should be insulated from having to work. While implicitly, it is ok for other people to have to work or pay taxes to fund that privilege. Often that attitude is easy to adopt when you forget who's paying the bills.


> students as a special class of people who should be insulated from having to work

You already believe that, you just disagree on the definition on student. Or should we take 14 year olds out of school and send them back into the coal mines?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: