Lock free is kind of an overloaded term that can mean a variety of things depending on what the user is thinking. Usually the goal is being able to make forward progress even if one thread is context switched out by the OS scheduler, which might be called wait-free or non-blocking. Using mutexes (unless you can prevent OS scheduling, interrupts, etc) makes this property impossible to achieve. In general, MPSC queues are super fast and there's no real reason to prefer a locked queue.
> In general, MPSC queues are super fast and there's no real reason to prefer a locked queue.
There's one significant advantage that a locked vector or deque has over MPSC/MPMC queues: the consumers can dequeue all messages in a single operation by locking the vector, swapping it with an empty vector (typically, that's just 3 words), and locking it again. That's such a simple operation that it will typically be as fast or even faster than a single pop-one-message operation in an MPSC/MPMP. Similarly, if the vector is empty, a producer can push any number of messages in a single, constant-time operation.
