> To your point, the difference in total payroll expense is $1,381. I'm sure my overall point does not sway on $1,381. Yet this difference will be almost exactly offset by the $7650 deduction allowed against Federal income tax!
Why would you compare the difference in payroll expense to the deduction against Federal income tax? What are you trying to get at with that? It doesn't make sense to talk about that.
Also, on your current numbers, the deduction the 1099 worker gets (half of the self-employment tax) is more than that ($8,340.87 vs. $7,650), but it still leaves the 1099 worker with a higher income subject to income tax than the W-2 worker, so it doesn't "make up" for anything -- the actual total tax difference between the two is greater than the additional payroll tax paid by the 1099 worker, since the 1099 worker will also pay greater income tax, all other things being equal.
> To your point, the difference in total payroll expense is $1,381. I'm sure my overall point does not sway on $1,381. Yet this difference will be almost exactly offset by the $7650 deduction allowed against Federal income tax!
Why would you compare the difference in payroll expense to the deduction against Federal income tax? What are you trying to get at with that? It doesn't make sense to talk about that.
Also, on your current numbers, the deduction the 1099 worker gets (half of the self-employment tax) is more than that ($8,340.87 vs. $7,650), but it still leaves the 1099 worker with a higher income subject to income tax than the W-2 worker, so it doesn't "make up" for anything -- the actual total tax difference between the two is greater than the additional payroll tax paid by the 1099 worker, since the 1099 worker will also pay greater income tax, all other things being equal.